Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Canadian-Style Health Care? Be Careful What You Wish For

"The beginning of May marks the end of income tax season in Canada. ...over one-half of the personal income taxes Canadians just paid in aggregate are required to cover the cost of our taxpayerfunded health care program. Given this level of expenditure, you might expect that Canadians receive world-class access to health care. But the evidence demonstrates that this is not so.
_______________________________________
waiting lists for access to health care in Canada
reached a new all-time high of 18.3 weeks from
referral to treatment... this wait time is 54%
longer than the median wait time of 11.9 weeks
back in 1997.

_______________________________________

Consider Canada’s waiting lists. In 2007, waiting lists for access to health care in Canada reached a new all-time high of 18.3 weeks from general practitioner referral to treatment by a specialist. Despite substantial increases in both health spending and federal cash transfers to the provinces for health care over the last decade or so, this wait time is 54% longer than the overall median wait time of 11.9 weeks back in 1997.


■ Canadians were more likely to experience waiting times of more than six months for elective surgery than Australians, Germans, the Dutch, and New Zealanders, but slightly less likely than patients in the United Kingdom;
■ Canadians were least likely among the six nations to wait less than one month for elective surgery;
■ Canadians were most likely to wait six days or longer to see a doctor when ill, and were least likely among the six universal access nations surveyed to receive an appointment the same day or the next day.

Access to medical technologies is also relatively poor in Canada. In a recent comparison of age-adjusted inventories of medical technologies, Canada ranked 13th of 24 nations for which data was available in terms of MRI machines per million population. It ranked 18th of 24 nations for CT scanners per million population, seventh of 17 for mammographs per million population, and tied for second last among 20 nations for lithotripters per million population. Clearly, Canada’s relatively high expenditures are buying neither quick access to care nor high tech health care services for the population.


Among 28 developed nations that maintain universal approaches to health insurance, a recent comparison found Canada ranked 24th in the age-adjusted number of physicians per thousand population.


Statistics Canada determined in 2005 that more than 1.3 million Canadians could not find a regular physician, while a recent estimate suggested that the number of Canadians without a regular physician was around five million.

That is hardly the sort of access you might expect from the developed world’s third most expensive universal access health insurance system."

Nadeem Esmail

No comments: