Friday, July 17, 2009

The 'Public Option' Health-Care Scam

"Market dominance doesn't necessarily mean insufficient competition. Microsoft's dominance of software didn't prevent the rise of Google, and Google's dominance of search-engine traffic didn't prevent Microsoft from offering Bing. If a few health insurance providers were suppressing competition at the expense of consumers, you'd expect to see obscene profits. But net profit margins in the business run about 3 percent, only slightly better than the median for all industries.
_________________________

Competition is healthy,
but how are private companies
supposed to compete with an
operation that can tap the Treasury?
_________________________

There are reasons, though, to think that the president's real enthusiasm is not for competition but for government expansion. Free-market advocates want to foster competition by letting consumers in one state buy coverage offered in other states. If WellPoint has more than half the business in Indiana, why not let Indiana residents or companies go to California or Minnesota to see if they can find options that are cheaper or better?

But the administration and its allies show no interest in removing that particular barrier to competition. Maybe that's because it would reduce the power of state regulators to boss insurers around.

Nor does Obama believe in fostering competition in other health insurance realms -- such as existing government health insurance programs. John Goodman, head of the National Center for Policy Analysis, suggests letting Americans enrolled in Medicare, Medicaid and the State Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) select a voucher to buy private coverage if they want. Don't hold your breath waiting for the administration to push that idea."
Steve Chapman, Chicago Tribune

No comments: