Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Sound Bite Politics

There are a lot of facets to the cost of health care. However, there is no denying that mandated coverages and insurance laws are a big reason for the some of the high costs - especially in states that have high medical costs. The graph below shows the average costs of medical insurance state-by-state.
_________________________

That kind of variation couldn't exist in a
competitive market for health insurance.
_________________________

For an insurance company, it is like having 50 bosses. Each state has its own insurance commissioner - as well as its own legislature. To say "We need to be able to sell insurance across state lines" is a great sound bite, but to do that you have to understand what is involved:
  • Effectively disband the 50 state insurance departments. If we can sell across state lines, their rules will not be needed? When was the last time you heard of 50 government department getting dis-banded?
  • Tell the state politicians that their laws and opinions on insurance do not matter anymore. When was the last time a politician agreed to giving up power?
Don't get me wrong, I am in favor of being able to sell insurance without the mandated coverages currently required (assuming the consumer is aware of the differences in products). As economics professor Mark Perry stated, "The average health insurance ranges from a low of $1,254 in Wisconsin to a high of $8,537 in Massachusetts, and the national average is $2,613. That kind of variation couldn't exist in a competitive market for health insurance. Interstate competition for health insurance would go a long way towards bringing health insurance costs down."

I just think it is not going to be able to be fixed in a sound bite.

(click on image to enlarge it)

No comments: