Monday, December 8, 2008

When A Check-Up Is Not A Check-Up - Part 2

Previously, we talked about the problems some people encounter when they have a check-up that is not covered by their insurance. Let’s talk about some of the reasons why check-ups are not considered check-ups by the insurance carrier.

First, let's consider billing codes. In most cases, this is the root of the problem. There are thousands of billing codes. Each procedure and each diagnosis has its own code. There are even different codes depending on the severity or complexity of the condition or procedure. These billing codes are what insurance carriers use to determine, among other things; 1) if a visit covered, 2) if it is a preventive visit, and 3) how much they reimburse the provider.

Now that we have billing codes as a background, let's look at some scenarios where we have seen conflict between what a client thought was a covered visit and what the insurance carrier said.

A visit is more than a check up: Frequently we get calls from clients who have been for a check-up recently, and they get a bill for the visit. The visit is for an 'allowable' preventive care visit, but the insurance company sends a bill regardless. In most cases, it turns out that the client is asking the physician about a specific condition during the visit. The annual well-visit to your child's pediatrician turns into something else when you ask them about the wart on your son's finger. That simple question about the wart causes another billing code to show up on the form sent to the insurance carrier. To make matters worse, insurance carriers are not consistent in how they treat this. Some carriers will consider the visit in the example above to be considered 'preventive' if the check-up code is listed first. Others will not pay if there is any other code on the form.

A visit is too soon: Your plan allows a certain type of visit once a year. You go for the same visit 364 days since the last one. Guess what, Sparky? It will probably be denied. The computer sees two visits in a 365 day period, and it denies the second one. This is nothing personal. In fact, that is the problem. There is nothing personal about it.

A visit is exactly what it is supposed to be: This particular incident is usually the result of a billing code error. The wrong box was checked, or the wrong code was listed. I worked on an incident where a man was billed for a 'female-only' procedure. When we started researching it, it was apparent to everyone what happened. The claim was re-filed, and everything was corrected. But once the wrong code was put on the form and it was transmitted electronically to the carrier, it was not really looked at by anyone until you receive the EOB (Explanation of Benefits) and see that the claim was denied.

Before we wrap up, let me give you an example of where the insurance carrier just plain had it wrong. A client had a new insurance carrier and went to have his annual eye exam. After the exam, he received the EOB saying the visit was not covered as 'preventive.' Then he received the bill for the exam. We looked into it and found out the billing code was for near-sightedness. That made sense since the patient had been wearing glasses for 30 years. Nothing was new here. We contacted the carrier, and they said the claim was denied because the billing code was for a diagnosis of near-sightedness, not a check-up. Huh? The conversation went something like this,

"You are telling me you cannot classify the claim as 'preventive' because he was diagnosed as being near-sighted."
"Correct."
"Even though he has been wearing glasses all of his adult life?"
"Yes sir."
"If he were not near-sighted and did not need glasses after the check-up, would you have paid the claim?"
"Yes sir."
"Does that make sense to you?"
"No sir."

In the end, the claim was paid. The insurance carrier changed their system to pay these claims.

Ultimately, the problem had as much to do with legislation as anything. In most of these instances, the individuals involved have and HRA or HSA. These high deductible plans are relatively new and are still evolving. The legislation covering these programs was put through pretty quickly and is evolving, too. To the carriers' credit, they offer to cover preventive visits in an attempt to get people to avoid skipping them because of the cost (since the individual would normally be responsible for the cost because of the high deductible). Until recently, there was no need to segment out these preventive visits. So now the carriers are trying to play catch-up to some degree in getting their systems to adapt to these new plan designs.

So if you have a claim and you wonder why it was not paid, call the carrier and ask questions. If you are still not satisfied with the answer, contact your broker and ask them to help you. (And if your broker says he does not do that, call us. We will be happy to help you).

No comments: