Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Unconstitutional

While the idea of a "public health option" is flawed for a host of reasons, Sen. Orrin Hatch has written a piece explaining why a "requirement" to have health insurance, and the subsequent "fine" imposed on those who do not have insurance, is unconstitutional.
'The liberty we enjoy in America requires limits on government power, and those limits come primarily from the Constitution. Our written Constitution delegates only certain powers to the federal government and Congress must point to at least one of them as authority to pass legislation.

This means, of course, that the Constitution might not allow some things Congress might want to do. Some provisions of the Finance Committee's health care bill are in this category. It would, for example, require nearly everyone to purchase health care insurance. Failure to do so could result in an "excise tax" to be assessed through the tax code and collected by the IRS….
_________________________

if politics trumps the Constitution,
the Constitution cannot limit government
and, therefore, cannot protect liberty.
_________________________

For the first time, the federal government would be ordering Americans to buy a particular product or service they had not chosen to purchase. Rather than regulate an activity in which individuals chose to engage, Congress would be requiring an activity in which individuals had chosen not to engage.


The nonpartisan Congressional Research Service issued a report concluding this is a completely novel, unprecedented constitutional issue….

Another constitutional problem with the individual mandate is that the penalty for failing to purchase health insurance is, in fact, not the excise tax that the Finance Committee bill says it is. It is really not a tax at all, but a fine masquerading as a tax. An excise tax is a tax on the sale of goods or services, such as a gasoline tax. If you do not buy gas, however, you do not pay the gas tax." Read more.
Orrin G. Hatch, Utah Republican, is a senior member of the Senate Finance Committee.

No comments: